Malius wrote:It destroys children and causes them to ruin their lives and those of the people around them. Warhammer does not.
meh unles you are like me and spend all the money of others around you to get warhammer
lol, but i personally agree with what pmpn8ez has said.
the reason why i detest rap and what passes for r'n'b (what ever happened to rythem on blues?) is the fact that it encourages a culture of people who are anti-social, and menacing to others around them. Pmpn8ez is right, if you rap about drugs and killing, there will always be those who listen and take it the wrong way.
You mean like rock. And punk. And metal. And most genres of music? It is simple bigotry to be applying these traits to rap as if it were both 1) exclusive to the genre, which is far from the truth, and b) as if rap was some monotheic entity as opposed to one of the more diverse genres around.
Plenty of rap is about politics, religion, is opposed to violence, and in many cases is opposed in a direct fashoin to these exact stereotypes everyone keeps spouting here. It disturbs me incredibly that people are applying these stereotypes, and I have a hard time at this point thinking this isnt somehow attached to most rappers being black. All these stereotypes coiuld just as easily be applied to many many other genres of music (techno and druge use, rock and drug use and degredation of women and rape and violence, metal and violence and anti-social and criminal behavior, etc etc). Exclusively applying these stereotypes to rap implies that there is some additional element singling the genre out. Unless all you guys complaining about these features of rap, as opposed to its aesthetic, actually dont listen to rock, metal, punk, early country, swing, bebop, techno, and anything else with this kind of content, you are either being hypocrites, or are simply lying about your reasons for disliking rap. And having read the music threads on a number of occasions, I know a lot of the people here who cite rap as being a bad influence like rock and metal in particular, which is complete hipocrisy.
Sorry, I don't remember a bunch of adults who play with fantasy toy soldiers going out and condoning drug use, killing people, and breaking the law. We influence kids, yes, but in a different way.
Warhammer sets up a militaristic psychology in youths and glorifies violence, sex, rape, human sacrifice, and any other number of unethical activities. BUt most of us recognize it as entertainment. So it is with rap. I can think of very few ccasions where I have seen a rapper, in an interview or any other context outside of a rap video, condone violence or rape or any of these things. On the contrary, I have seen a great number of rappers actively engaged in work to reduce these things by working with non-profits or media venues. Most people have the common sense to distringuish between the content of a song and how they actually live their lives. I certainly havent started any major revolutions or burned down corporate buildings because I listen to The Coup or Dead Kennedys. As far as I can tell, the only way society has actually been all that influenced by rap is in aesthetic. People dress differently than they did ten years ago. Other than that I can see very little perceivable difference in peoples behavior, and I know crime rates in general have dropped around the country Whoopdity doo. So basically these rappers have got people to dress in baggy clothes and wear doo rags and speak differently. I hardly see that as a threat to our social fabric.
Zentaricai wrote:you know somethin Archduke, I'll comment and lecture on anything I please---and you don't have to be an "expert" in a certain area to have an opinion on it one way or another.
Excuse me. Let me rephrase. You shouldnt pass judgment on something you know nothing about, unless you want to appear uninformed, bigoted, narrow minded, or some combination there of. Naturally one is entitled to poorly formulated opinions.
infection wrote:'ve got it! chavs like RAP cos its easy to sing and make and means nothing! I have proof of how simple the songs are which also shows why people who like real musicians (and/or can play an instrument) despise RAP so much
A lot of rap is extremly complex lyrically and has a very clear and strong mesage. And it is simply innacurate to suggest that "real" musicians disdain rap. PLenty of the worlds most talented musicians collaberate with rappers. Most of the best musicians are pretty open minded, which has a lot to do with ones talent. A person open minded enough to work with artists of different genres will have a much broaders set of musical skills to work with.
What is evident with this whole thread is that a lot of people here seem to have stereotypes about rappers, that are quite apparently uninfomred (as stereotypes tend to be), generalized to the group regardless of individual differences that are rife within the genre, and which is actively hostile towards the group. Stereotypes are a pretty uncritical way to view any group, be they rappers, a culture group, or anyone else. If you dont like rap, fine, but dont go making broad statements about a genre you clearly know nothing about, unless you want to sound ignorant or racist or elitist. Its a great way to offend people, and to help along discriminatory behavior, but stereotypes arent useful for much else. Its an intellectually and emotionally lazy thing to clasify the world in this manner. If you dont like rap purely because of how it sounds, that one thing. But distinguish that from calling all rappers "criminals" and making other such completely uninformed patently false statements that just sound racist and bigoted. I can readily supply a list of 20 rappers who are none of the things people have complained about if anyone is interested, just to illustrate that these stereotypes are wrong, and I can also provide lengthy lists of musicians from many other genres whose lyrics are just as "criminal" in content.